ERIC BAERREN: A climate-change skeptic confirms global warming

Published: Friday, October 28, 2011

There were, if you were paying attention last week, headlines that read essentially, “The thing that we knew all along is true, after all!”

The sad fact is that the confirmation was, in fact, the real news. It was a statement on the sad statement of how the Land of the Free perceives science.

A Berkeley physicist with the last name of Muller had assembled what he called a crack team of scientists, and with money that came in part from the infamous Koch brothers, declared his intention to finally settle the matter of whether the data supported the notion that the globe is warming.

Thanks to Muller’s past contrarian-sounding statements and the infusion of money from the ignorati, there was the distinct possibility that the eternal game of whack-a-mole that drives climate politics in this nation would continue, but with a more respectable sheen. This was a matter of concern for climate scientists and people who generally don’t believe that they are part of a massive global plot to shackle mankind in communist slavery; it was a matter of barely concealed delight among contrarians. Anthony Watts, one of the most prominent and vocal of climate contrarians, in fact vowed to accept Muller’s findings.

Well, Muller released his findings last week, and the only thing surprising about them is that anyone expected him to find that climate scientists have gotten everything wrong. In fact, he said that they’ve gotten things mostly right. A new and fresh look at the data failed to turn up anything out of order. Dog bites man.

Watts, a vocal critic of the peer review process right up until the announcement, announced that he was not able to accept Muller’s findings until they’d gone through proper peer review. In other words, he’ll wait around until a conclusion that doesn’t make him look like an utter fool is reached … even if one never presents itself.

For the rest of you, the results of Muller’s findings can be distilled to this: The atmosphere, of course, is warming.

Savvy contrarians were nonplused. Of course the world is warming. Everyone knows that. The question is whether mankind is driving it. It was as if it was silly for anyone to suggest otherwise.

Except that as recently as six months ago, climate contrarians were mostly arguing that we were in the middle of a cooling cycle, that things weren’t getting warmer but instead cooler. It’d been going on since 1998, and with sunspot activity expected to reach a low point in its 12-year cycle it was going to get even cooler. Between then and now came the disturbing news that last year was one of the hottest in recorded history, and that this year could well rank right up there.

If all that sounds inconsistent or even incoherent, it’s because consistency and coherence never have been hallmarks of climate contrarians. The unifying idea of their argument is that we need not change our behavior because of global warming. Anything that suggests the contrary is heresy; anything that abets it is welcome.

How they arrive at their destination changes depending on the day, possibly by the position of the sun and however their own internal sense of paranoia is affected by changes in the Earth’s magnetic field. Either the atmosphere is not warming, or it is not warming significantly or it is warming due to natural fluctuations. Sprinkled in between you can be assured of hearing that someone talked about global cooling in the 70s, that there was a bigger area of ice this year than last, or that Al Gore is fat and once flew on a jet. Take one from menu A and one from menu B, and make sure you get your complimentary egg roll before walking out the door.

Muller’s findings have been followed by what has become a familiar flow of editorial pieces: The contrarians are increasingly isolated, and that it’s time to have an adult conversation about climate and energy.

Of course we ought to do that, but the contrarians have been isolated for a very long time. The problem is that they don’t know it, and don’t know how alone they really are when it comes to support from scientists (from across basically every discipline). People who are unaware of how out-of-touch they are with reality aren’t going to give up just because they are once again told that they’re living in a fantasy world. In fact, since last week, contrarians have turned on Muller, suggesting that he was a sort of climate Manchurian candidate all along.

To longtime observers of the issue, this was something to be expected. Climate contrarians operate in their own echo chamber, and those who depart from it are considered worse than the enemy. They are considered apostates of the cause. A mere objective analysis of the evidence isn’t going to change their minds. In fact, it’s just evidence that the game has been fixed against them all along.

Eric Baerren is a Morning Sun columnist. He can be found at www.michiganliberal.com and can be reached at ebaerren@gmail.com.

Original Link: http://www.themorningsun.com/articles/2011/10/28/opinion/doc4ea9a149367a4444496959.txt?viewmode=fullstory

2 Responses to “ERIC BAERREN: A climate-change skeptic confirms global warming”

Gravatar

discount codes amazon coupons tv Says:

discount codes amazon coupons tv

Portland Eco-Friendly Transportation, Sustainable Commuter Practices, Business Shuttle Services, ERIC BAERREN: A climate-change skeptic confirms global warming

Gravatar

click the next web page Says:

click the next web page

Portland Eco-Friendly Transportation, Sustainable Commuter Practices, Business Shuttle Services, ERIC BAERREN: A climate-change skeptic confirms global warming

Leave a Reply

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.

Search

Search the EcoShuttle site to find information about us, as well as interesting facts about the Environment.

Our Friendly Shuttles

Currently powered by 100% biodiesel.

Browse by Category

100% biodiesel 100 billion 1869 2010 Affordable Health Care Act 2012 2013 4th of July Adam Yauch adopt a highway Ages and Ages agriculture air pollution air port transportation Alberta Canada Alexana Winery algae algae blooms alternative energy American Chemistry Council Americans animal exctinction animal fats animals apple Archery Summit Athens Atlants Falcons b20 b99 Bamboo Sushi Bangladesh Barack Obama basic rights bear Beastie Boys beer Bengals Berkeley Better Living Show big oil bike bike lanes BikeBar bikes Bill Clinton biodiesel biodynamics Birdfest and Bluegrass Birdfest and Bluegrass Nature Festival birth rate Bison Organic Brewing Black Friday Black Mountain BLIZZAKS blog Bluefin Tuna bluegrass Blues Fest Bobcats Booker T bourbon Bravo Wedding Affair Brazil brew tours brewpubs Buddy Guy bus buses Business Success buy local California Cape Wind Project carbon carbon dioxide carbon emissions carbon foot print carbon legacy Carbon Neutral Challenge carless in portland cars Central America Century Link Field Champoeg Farms charter Chehalem Winery Chernobyl Chicago Chicago Cubs Chicago River China Christmas Christmas tree Cincinnati Reds Cinco De Mayo clean coal clean energy clean energy initiatives Clean Fuels Now climate change coal coal ash cold water laundry colonizing the ocean Columbia Boulevard Columbia Gorge Columbia River Gorge Committed Wedding Event Community Supported Agriculture compost consumption Cooper Mountain Wines cost effective CSM Monitor Cuyahoga River cyclist Daryl Hanna Dave Kestenbaum Daves Killer Bread Dawn of the Bed De Ponte Cellars debris department of defense deposits Dhani Jones dogs dolphins Domaine Drouhin Dr. Robert Ballard drilling drive less Duck Pond eco friendly eco friendly christmas tree eco friendly holiday eco friendly transportation eco portland eco toys ecofriendly EcoHouse ecoShuttle Ecotrope election 2012 electric cars electricity energy environment Environmental Defense EPA facebook Fake Plastic Trees fall travel fauna federal government first thursday fiscal responsibility fish deformities Fish Tale Organic Beer Fisker Karma. Chevy Volt food food supply food waste football Forbes Ford forest park Fourth of July fracking fun Galactic Galleria building George H.W. Bush George W. Bush Germany Glass Candy Glen Jackson Bridge global warming Google Gorge Tour Gov. Schwarzenegger Grain and Gristle Great Willamette Cleanup green beer Green Coach Certification green gifts green house gases green oregon Green Path Green Path Transfers green portland Green Portland Tours green roofs Green Sports Alliance green sprouts Green Tips green transportation green wedding greenest city in america greenloop Grochau Cellars Growing Gardens GrowingGardens growler Happy Hour Holiday Waste Hood River Fruit Loop Hood River Wine Tour hopworks Hopworks Urban Brewery hot green Hotel Monaco Hotel Oregon hoyt arboretum Hurricane Sandy hydrothermal energy Iberdrola Renewables Indiana interstate bicycle highway Italy Ivan Neville Jamal Crawford James Inhofe Jason Jesse and Fiona Yun junk to funk Kentucky Keystone XL Pipeline KGW Lake Michigan Las Vegas LEED Certified Left Coast Cellars Lemelson Vineyards Les Schwab Amphitheatre license plates Little Big Branch lobbyists lobsterman lungs MAC Maceo Parker Macindoe Family Cellars Mark Klosterman Mayor Emanuel McMenamins mcminnville Meatless Monday Memorial Day Miami Erie Canal Microsoft migrating birds military Miss Teen Earth Mississippi River mt hood Mt. Hood Scenic Highway Multnomah Falls MusicFest Northwest MusicfestNW New Jersey New Seasons New Year New York New York City New York Times NFL Niger Nissan Leaf NOAA non partisan northeast Northwest Shingle Recyclers NPR Obama Administration ocean off shore oil platform Ogallala Aquifer Ohio Ohio University oil oil platforms Olympia Olympia Snowe Oregon oregon beaches Oregon Ducks Oregon State University Oregon wines oregon zoo organic coffee overpopulation Ovie Mughelli partisan party pdx pedestrians Philadelphia Eagles pickathon Pink Floyd plastic plastic bag ban plastic bags plate and pitchfork polar ice caps politicians pollution population growth portland Portland Oregon portland oregon in the fall Portland tours Portland Trailblazers powells books preservation President Obama Presidential campaigns Presidential Debates Prius privatized recycling project syndicate pub crawls R99 rain forests Rainbow Wedding Expo rainforest raised gardens recreation recycle recycling Red Lion renewable renewable energy Renewable energy ghost towns reuse Rex Hill Ridgefield National Wildlife Refuge Ridgefield Nature Preserve roads Robert Cray Rose Festival Rose Garden Arena safety Safeway Waterfront Blues Festival Sam Adams Sasquatch Music Festival Sauvie Island Sauvie Island Organics Science Daily Seahawks Seattle Seattle Seahawks see portland sewage runoff sharks Sherwood shuttles Siria Bojorquez Small Business Saturday Smith Berry Farms Smithsonian Institue snow Sokol Blosser solar energy solar power Solyndra Soter Vineyards spell check spiders State of the Union stem cell research Steve Miller Band Steven Chu Stoller Vineyards studded tires stumptown coffee Styrofoam subway summer Sun Gold Farms Sunnyside superfund site superstorm sustainability sustainable energy sustainable gift wrapping sustainable living sustainable transportation sustainable travel SW Washington Talk of the Nation Science Friday Tesla Texas Thanksgiving the Antlers The Flaming Lips the Wall Thee Oh Sees Three MIle Island Titanic Toronto tours toxins Toyohashi University of Technology Toyota Prius Trail Blazers transfer service transportation trash trashion travel oregon travel portland Travelocity trees University of Vermont Univore used cooking oil Van Wert Vancouver Canucks vegetable oil veggie oil Viridian Farms washington washington park oregon Washington Post waste free wedding Waterfront Blues Fest waterfront blues festival weddings weekend Will Sampson Willamette River Willamette Riverkeepers Willamette Valley Willamette Valley Vineyards Wilsonville wind energy wind farm wind farms wind power wind turbines Winderlea Vineyards wine wine tasting wine tour wine tours winter Yale Yale Project on Climate Change Communication Yucca Mountain Zanzibar

The Green Commuter

Sign Up for our Quarterly Newsletter to find out what we and the rest of the industry are doing to make Green Commuting work.